Lowest Failure Rate Franchises: Ranked by SBA Charge-Off

The franchise industry claims a 90% success rate. The reality, based on 94,000+ resolved SBA loans, is a 16.0% overall charge-off rate. But averages hide the extremes. Some franchise brands have a perfect 0% charge-off rate across hundreds of loans. Others exceed 50%. The brand you choose matters more than the category, the investment size, or even the location.

We ranked every brand with a qualifying SBA sample (20 or more loans spread across multiple independent lenders) by charge-off rate. Here are the lowest-rate franchise investments based on actual loan performance — every brand below has a true 0% charge-off rate.

Top 6 franchises by lowest SBA charge-off rate (20+ loans)

What 0% charge-off rates actually mean

A 0% SBA charge-off rate means that every borrower who took an SBA loan to open or expand that franchise brand either paid the loan in full or is still current on payments. Not a single lender wrote off a loss. For brands with 100+ loans, this is statistically significant and indicates consistent, predictable unit economics.

Christian Brothers Automotive leads with 295 loans at 0.0% default. Nothing Bundt Cakes has 283 loans at 0.0%. At these volumes, the probability of the result being a statistical accident is negligible. These brands have structural advantages that protect franchisees from failure.

Categories with the lowest charge-off rates

The lowest-default brands cluster in specific categories:

• Healthcare: Recurring, often non-discretionary demand gives the category a 7.2% average charge-off rate.
• Senior care: Visiting Angels at 0.0% on 138 loans. Demographic tailwinds and recurring care contracts give the category a 8.2% average — among the lowest of any franchise category.
• Home services: Benjamin Franklin Plumbing at 0.0% on 51 loans. Low overhead, recurring revenue, and aging housing stock create consistent demand. See our home service franchise guide.
• QSR: Nothing Bundt Cakes at 0.0% on 283 loans. It is not the biggest QSR brand, but it has optimized unit economics that protect franchisee profitability. The QSR category overall has a 15.5% charge-off rate.

Low defaults and high revenue: the best of both

The brands that combine 0% defaults with disclosed revenue above $1M are the standouts:

How to use this data in your research

SBA charge-off rate should be one of the first things you check when evaluating a franchise. Here is how to contextualize it:

1. Compare to the category average. A 10% charge-off rate is below average for QSR (15.5%) but above average for lodging (5.9%). Context matters. See failure rates by industry.
2. Check the loan volume. A 0% rate on 3 loans is meaningless. A 0% rate on 200+ loans is a strong signal. We include loan count in every brand profile.
3. Cross-reference with revenue. A low charge-off rate combined with high disclosed revenue is the best-case scenario. Use the screener to filter by both metrics simultaneously.

The verdict

The franchises with the lowest charge-off rates share common traits: consistent unit economics, established brands, and business models that do not require heroic sales performance to break even. They span categories from lodging to QSR to home services. The unifying factor is that their operators reliably generate enough revenue to service their debt. That sounds obvious, but about 1 in 6franchise SBA borrowers fails to achieve it.

Methodology

SBA charge-off rates calculated from 7(a) loan records obtained through FOIA. Only brands with 20+ total loans were included to ensure statistical relevance. Revenue data from Item 19 of each brand's most recent FDD. See our full methodology.

Why sample size matters more than the rate itself

A 0% SBA charge-off rate is meaningless without loan volume context. A brand with 2 loans at 0% has proven nothing statistically — it could default on the very next loan. A brand with 295 loans at 0.0% (Christian Brothers Automotive) has demonstrated consistent, predictable unit economics across that many independent borrowers over multiple economic cycles. The threshold for statistical confidence is roughly 30 loans: below that, the charge-off rate is more noise than signal.

This is why our ranking requires a minimum of 20 SBA loans. Even at 20, the confidence interval is wide. At 50+ loans, you can start making reliable comparisons. At 100+ loans, you are looking at a brand where the business model has been stress-tested across enough operators and geographies to give genuine predictive value. When evaluating any franchise's SBA data, always check the loan count alongside the charge-off rate — the combination tells you far more than either number alone.

The bottom line

Failure rate is a metric most franchise buyers never check. The brands on this list have earned 0% SBA charge-off rates across substantial loan volumes — a distinction few franchise brands achieve. A low failure rate does not guarantee your success, but it tells you that the business model consistently produces enough revenue for operators to service their debt. In an industry where about 1 in 6 SBA-backed franchisees defaults, that signal is worth more than any revenue projection.

Related franchise research

Continue your research with our 7-Eleven franchise analysis, Ace Hardware franchise analysis, and best food franchises guide.