Meineke vs Carstar
Franchise Comparison 2026
FDDs: Meineke 2025, Carstar 2025SBA 7(a) data through FY2026Updated How we score
Both Meineke and Carstar are franchises in the automotive category. Meineke requires an investment of $225K – $1.2M while Carstar requires $298K – $804K. In terms of revenue, Carstar reports higher average gross sales at $3.2M. On SBA loan performance, Carstar has a lower charge-off rate (0.0%) compared to Meineke (27.1%). FranchiseVerdict rates Meineke C (Middle tier) and Carstar A (Strongest tier).
| Metric | Meineke | Carstar |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict Grade | ||
| Investment Range | $225K – $1.2M | $298K – $804K |
| Franchise Fee | $45K | $10K |
| Royalty Rate | Royalty Fees You are required to pay the greater of an annual minimum royalty in the amount of $20,800 or a calculated royalty based on the following percentages of Gross Revenues on the identified categories of Authorized Products and Services: 7% of exhaust systems 5.5% replacement of engines or transmissions, engine diagnostics, engine seals, mounts and gaskets, transmission mounts, scheduled maintenance 4% of batteries 3% of tires, state inspections, towing services, Emissions Inspections 5% of all other Authorized Products and Services (Note 3) On or before the day of each week that we periodically specify (the “Payment Day”), currently, Wednesday, you are required to pay the greater of 1/52 of the annual minimum royalty (which equals $400) or your calculated royalty We may modify the Payment Day and corresponding reporting period at any time. | 1.5% |
| Average Gross Sales (Item 19) | $971KOutlet subset | $3.2M |
| SBA Charge-Off Rate | 27.1% (490 resolved loans) | 0.0% (16 resolved loans) |
| Total Units | 716 | 471 |
| Unit Growth (YoY) | +14 units | +16 units |
| Year Began Franchising | 1972 | 1989 |
| FDD Year | 2025 | 2025 |
Investment Range
$225K – $1.2M
$298K – $804K
Franchise Fee
$45K
$10K
Royalty Rate
Royalty Fees You are required to pay the greater of an annual minimum royalty in the amount of $20,800 or a calculated royalty based on the following percentages of Gross Revenues on the identified categories of Authorized Products and Services: 7% of exhaust systems 5.5% replacement of engines or transmissions, engine diagnostics, engine seals, mounts and gaskets, transmission mounts, scheduled maintenance 4% of batteries 3% of tires, state inspections, towing services, Emissions Inspections 5% of all other Authorized Products and Services (Note 3) On or before the day of each week that we periodically specify (the “Payment Day”), currently, Wednesday, you are required to pay the greater of 1/52 of the annual minimum royalty (which equals $400) or your calculated royalty We may modify the Payment Day and corresponding reporting period at any time.
1.5%
Average Gross Sales (Item 19)
$971KOutlet subset
$3.2M
SBA Charge-Off Rate
27.1% (490 resolved loans)
0.0% (16 resolved loans)
Total Units
716
471
Unit Growth (YoY)
+14 units
+16 units
Year Began Franchising
1972
1989
FDD Year
2025
2025
Next step
Browse free
Every brand with an FDD on file, graded, with costs, disclosed sales and SBA records. No sign-in.Pro
For advisors and lenders working across many brands; inquire by email.