CARSTAR vs Maaco
Franchise Comparison 2026
Both CARSTAR and Maaco are automotive franchises. CARSTAR requires an investment of $298K – $804K while Maaco requires $196K – $644K. In terms of revenue, CARSTAR reports higher average unit revenue at $3.2M. On SBA loan performance, CARSTAR has a lower charge-off rate (0.0%) compared to Maaco (17.4%). FranchiseVerdict rates CARSTAR A (Strongest tier) and Maaco B (Above average).
| Metric | CARSTAR | Maaco |
|---|---|---|
| Verdict Grade | AStrongest tierStrongest tier | BAbove averageAbove average |
| Investment Range | $298K – $804K | $196K – $644K |
| Franchise Fee | $10K | $45K |
| Royalty Rate | Monthly Base Franchise Fee (greater of $1,000 or 1.5% of Monthly Base Volume) plus Monthly Growth Franchise Fee (4% of Gross Sales exceeding Monthly Base Volume) | 8.0% |
| Average Revenue (Item 19) | $3.2M | $1.6MOutlet subset |
| SBA Charge-Off Rate | 0.0% (40 loans) | 17.4% (612 loans) |
| Total Units | 471 | 363 |
| Unit Growth (YoY) | N/A | N/A |
| Year Began Franchising | 1989 | 1972 |
| FDD Year | 2025 | 2025 |
Investment Range
$298K – $804K
$196K – $644K
Franchise Fee
$10K
$45K
Royalty Rate
Monthly Base Franchise Fee (greater of $1,000 or 1.5% of Monthly Base Volume) plus Monthly Growth Franchise Fee (4% of Gross Sales exceeding Monthly Base Volume)
8.0%
Average Revenue (Item 19)
$3.2M
$1.6MOutlet subset
SBA Charge-Off Rate
0.0% (40 loans)
17.4% (612 loans)
Total Units
471
363
Unit Growth (YoY)
N/A
N/A
Year Began Franchising
1989
1972
FDD Year
2025
2025