FDD Items 3 & 4 · 2024 filing
Best Choice Roofing litigation history
What Best Choice Roofing disclosed about lawsuits, arbitrations and bankruptcy in the 2024 Franchise Disclosure Document. Item 3 lists the material legal actions a franchisor must report; Item 4 covers bankruptcy. This is the franchisor's own disclosure, not a court record, and not legal advice.
2024 FDD (Items 3 and 4)Updated How we score
Items 3 (litigation) & 4 (bankruptcy) at a glance
What the filing discloses
- Matters disclosed
- 2
- Item 3, as counted in the filing - the brand page prints the same count
- Largest settlement, franchisor's own cases
- None stated
- Bankruptcy (Item 4)
- Disclosed · an officer
- Franchisor, parent, predecessor or officer
- Filing year
- 2024
- Disclosures cover the prior ten years
Extracted from the 2024 Franchise Disclosure Document
Item 3: litigation
Case 1: BCR & Home Improvement v. Best Choice Roofing Savannah & Augusta (2018) - breach of contract/trademark infringement; settled with monetary payment. Case 2: BCR Franchising v. Herron et al (2023, refiled 2024) - breach of franchise agreement restrictive covenants; Tennessee lawsuit ongoing.
Item 3 (litigation) · 2 matters disclosed · 1 pending listed
Litigation cases
| Named party | Pending | Concluded | Not stated | Matters |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The franchisor and its predecessor | 1 | 1 | 0 | 2 |
| Material matters read | 1 | 1 | 0 | 2 |
Open case that names the franchisor (1)
Best Choice Roofing Franchising, LLC v. William Zachary Herron, Herron Family IRRV Trust, and Allstar Sales of NE Arkansas, LLC
pendingBrought by the franchisor · filed 2023-05-30 · Circuit Court of Craighead County, Arkansas; Chancery Court of Sumner County, Tennessee · 16JCV-23-816; 24CV-11
“… Civil Case No. 16JCV-23-816 (Circuit Court of Craighead County, Arkansas, filed May 30, 2023; refiled in Chancery Court of Sumner”p. 11
The franchisor: other matters · 1 matter
Concluded (1)
Best Choice Roofing & Home Improvement, Inc. v. Best Choice Roofing Savannah, LLC & Best Choice Roofing Augusta, LLC
settledBrought by the franchisor · filed 2018-07-06 · U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee · 3:18-cv-00615
“… Civil Action No. 3:18-cv-00615 (District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee, filed July 6, 2018) We filed a lawsuit against former licensees of ours for breach of contract, trademark infringement, and unfair competition.”p. 11
Item 3 lists the litigation the franchisor must disclose; a matter against a parent, an affiliate or a named officer is not a matter against the franchisor, and pending claims are allegations, not findings.
Disclosed in the 2024 Franchise Disclosure Document
Item 4: bankruptcy
CFO Andrea Morris filed Chapter 13 bankruptcy petition on June 6, 2018 (Case No. 3:18-bk-03774). Plan completed October 5, 2022; discharge entered October 28, 2022; case closed January 17, 2023.
Disclosure signals that moved the score
How this shows up in the verdict
- Two active/recent litigation cases involving breach of contract and trademark disputes signal franchisor-franchisee relationship dysfunction and legal exposure
- Explosive growth (63 units, from 6 to 18 franchised outlets in the latest year) combined with litigation suggests system may be adding unprofitable units or experiencing early terminations
The verdict grade is FranchiseVerdict's editorial assessment across SBA loan performance, unit growth, revenue and disclosure signals. It is not investment advice.
Before you weigh a lawsuit
How to read Item 3
A franchisor must disclose pending actions and any material civil action involving the franchise relationship, plus convictions or civil judgments for fraud, unfair or deceptive practices, or franchise-law violations, going back ten years. A case the franchisor brought against a franchisee counts too. Item 3 does not include every dispute: settled claims below the materiality line and matters resolved in private arbitration can be absent.
Questions worth asking current and former franchisees, using the contact list in Item 20:
- Were you, or anyone you know in the system, party to a dispute with the franchisor?
- Was it resolved by settlement, arbitration or a court, and on what terms?
- Has the number of disputes gone up or down since you signed?
Cite this page
Citation
FranchiseVerdict. "Best Choice Roofing litigation history." Source: 2024 Franchise Disclosure Document, Items 3 and 4. Updated November 14, 2026. https://franchiseverdict.com/brand/best-choice-roofing/litigation
Link for a web page
<a href="https://franchiseverdict.com/brand/best-choice-roofing/litigation">Best Choice Roofing litigation history (FranchiseVerdict)</a>
Free to quote with a link. Figures come from the filing or federal loan data named above; grades are FranchiseVerdict's editorial assessment, not investment advice. Press and data requests: press@franchiseverdict.com
Next step
Browse free
Every brand with an FDD on file, graded, with costs, disclosed sales and SBA records. No sign-in.Pro
For advisors and lenders working across many brands; inquire by email.