Auto Select franchise: cost, earnings and risks
2009 FDD, with page numbersUpdated
This data is from a 2009 FDD. Current terms may differ. Always verify with the franchisor's latest disclosure document.
Auto Select in brief
Auto Select is an automotive franchise providing auto repair, diagnostics, and maintenance. Opening one costs $110K – $160K under the 2009 FDD; Item 19 sales: not extracted. Our Verdict grade for Auto Select is B (50/100, Second tier), an editorial assessment, not investment advice: scale weighs on it most.
Quick verdict
Compared with the median of 99 Automotive brands.
p. 4
2009 FDD, Item 7, page 4 · older source… fee is $2,500, which may be waived at the discretion of Franchisor. The estimated initial investment required ranges from $110,000 to $160,000. …Quoted from the franchisor's filing.Read page 4 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing.Get the FDD PDF · $9
Better - Below the median: less cash needed
p. 8
2009 FDD, Item 5, page 8 · older source… in proceedings under the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. ITEM 5 INITIAL FRANCHISE FEE Auto Select charges a uniform initial franchise fee of $2,500 for each new franchise. …Quoted from the franchisor's filing.Read page 8 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing.Get the FDD PDF · $9
Better - Below the median: costs less
p. 4
2009 FDD, Item 7, page 4 · older sourceRead page 4 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing.Get the FDD PDF · $9Better - Below the median: less cash needed
p. 9
2009 FDD, Item 6, page 9 · older sourceContinuing Fees The greater of $700 or Five percent (5% …Quoted from the franchisor's filing.Read page 9 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing.Get the FDD PDF · $9
Better - Below the median: costs less
Item 12
2009 FDD, Item 12 · older sourceRead Item 12 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing (where).Get the FDD PDF · $9Worse - no protection
p. 22
2009 FDD, Item 15, page 22 · older sourceRead page 22 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing.Get the FDD PDF · $9Neutral - no benchmark
p. 8
2009 FDD, Item 3, page 8 · older sourceRead page 8 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing.Get the FDD PDF · $9Review - some history
✓Better than median✕WorseWithin 10% or no benchmark!Read the details
Better or worse means more than 10% from the median. Blue links open the source page. Editorial assessment, not investment advice. Method
The $19 report: every fee, the Item 20 unit counts and attorney questions by Item, as a PDF. One-time; full refund within 7 days if the data does not match the FDD.
Compare:Spiffygrade BHHO Carbon Clean Systemsgrade BKennedy Transmission® Brake & Auto Servicegrade B
Quick facts, each with its FDD Item and page
- Category
- Automotive
- Franchisor (legal entity)
- Auto Select, Inc., organized in Wisconsinp. 7
- Headquarters
- Wisconsinp. 7
- Franchising since
- 2005p. 7
- CEO
- Michael J. Molitor, Sr.p. 8
FranchiseVerdict grade
50/100
Second tier
50 this brand58 Automotive medianlikely 25–75: narrower with more SBA loans and a newer filing (very low confidence)
Higher is better · an editorial assessment, not investment advice
#1,725 of 3,063 graded brands
- Weighs on it: Scale: Franchising since 2005
- Weighs on it: Transparency: Item 19 status not confirmed
2009 FDDGraded on the 2009 filing.
What does an Auto Select franchise cost?
5.0% of sales a year
Royalty and ad fund, on top of the startup cost. Item 19 gives no usable average sales, so no yearly dollars.
p. 9
2009 FDD, Item 6, page 9 · older sourceContinuing Fees The greater of $700 or Five percent (5% …Quoted from the franchisor's filing.Read page 9 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing.Get the FDD PDF · $9
Cost breakdown
p. 14
2009 FDD, page 14 · older sourceRead page 14 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing.Get the FDD PDF · $9Source: FDD 2009 · Items 5–7 (fees and startup costs)
The filing prints no Item 7 TOTAL row that equals this range; the headline is the cover's stated total. Its own line items add to $116,900 to $176,200. The total is shown as the franchisor printed it; the lines are listed as printed. 2009-era UFOC-style 'Franchise Offering Circular' (36 pp.). The only Item 7 chart (pp.11-12) lists ten expenditure lines and prints NO TOTAL row, so no table TOTAL can equal the headline.
Do you qualify? The filing states no minimum net worth or liquid capital; check the franchisor's site for its own requirements. Ask Auto Select, Inc. (Item 1: 614 Lances Circle, Hatley, WI 54440) and your lender what they require, and keep living costs for the first year outside the deal.
Full Item 7 breakdown10 line items
Initial investment breakdown
| Line item | Low | High | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Initial Franchise Fee | $2.5K | $2.5K | |
| Travel and Living Expenses During Training | $2K | $2K | |
| Real Estate Rent + Security Deposit or Purchase | $3K | $5K | |
| Opening Inventory | $20K | $30K | |
| Equipment, Signs, Small Tools and Freight | $80K | $120K | |
| Computer System | $1.5K | $2.5K | |
| Administrative Supplies | $1K | $1K | |
| Insurance | $900 | $1.2K | |
| Pre-paid Expenses | $1K | $2K | |
| Working Capital | $5K | $10K | |
| Total initial investment | $110K | $160K |
When each item is due
- Initial Franchise Fee
- With submission of application or may be waived by Franchisor
- Travel and Living Expenses During Training
- As incurred
- Real Estate Rent + Security Deposit or Purchase
- As incurred
- Opening Inventory
- At training
- Equipment, Signs, Small Tools and Freight
- Before opening
- Computer System
- Before opening
- Administrative Supplies
- Before opening
- Insurance
- Before opening
- Pre-paid Expenses
- Before opening
- Working Capital
- As incurred
Line items extracted from FDD Item 7. Ranges reflect the franchisor's stated low and high per line. The total row is the total as printed in Item 7; the lines above add to $116,900 to $176,200, $16,200 at most from the printed total, which is the figure shown. Actual costs may fall outside this range depending on market and build-out scope.
Item 6 · what you pay once you are open
Ongoing fees
| Fee | Amount |
|---|---|
| RoyaltyPercentage of sales; paid weekly (Item 6). Item 6: Greater of $700 or 5% of Gross Receipts (weekly) | 5.0% of gross sales |
| Marketing / ad fund | 0.0% |
| Transfer fee | $1,500 |
| Total fee loadbelow the Automotive median of 7.5% (lean) | 5.0% of sales |
How much do Auto Select units make?
Not extracted
What Item 19 of the filing says instead of a sales figure.
Groups, ranges and the one-unit box
Source: FDD 2009 · Item 19 (sales and earnings)
Items 6 (other fees), 7 (startup costs) and 19 (sales and earnings) · assumptions labeled
What you could make and lose: one unit
What one Auto Select unit would ask of you, from the filing's Item 7 total and labeled assumptions.
How these figures are worked out
- Loan (assumption): 80% of the $135K Item 7 midpoint is a $108K loan, paid over 10 years at 10.5%: $17K a year. SBA 7(a)-style terms on a long-term rate; your lender sets yours.
What you put at risk
Your own cash in: about $27K Assumption (the part the loan does not cover of the $135K Item 7 midpoint), plus whatever anything Item 7 leaves out (its notes say what). The loan is $108K.
Personal guarantee. SBA 7(a) loans require a personal guarantee from anyone who owns 20% or more of the business. If the unit cannot pay, the lender can collect from you personally, which can include your savings and your home. The worst case is losing the cash you put in and still owing the rest of the loan.
Gross sales are not profit, and none of these figures is take-home pay until tax and every operating cost are paid. The assumptions are ours, not the filing's. Not investment advice.
Returns model: one unit, several units, buying an existing unit (editable, pre-filled from this filing).
Item 19 · Source: 2009 FDD · filed by Auto Select, Inc.
Financial performance
We have not established what this franchisor's Item 19 says. The FDD on file either has no locatable Item 19 or could not be read, so no figure is published here.
Auto Select SBA loans and unit growth
No SBA 7(a) loans matched to this brand.
States and SBA detail
Item 20 (outlet counts) · unit dynamics
The growth chart
No multi-year history on file here and no opening or closing activity in the last reporting year.
Where the outlets are · Item 20 owner list
23 current outlets in 1 state.
- WI
Counts only, from the list the franchisor prints in Item 20. The contact details are for your own due diligence and are not shown here.
Government records
SBA loan data
Matched to this brand from SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan records.
No SBA loan data available for this brand.
Auto Select lawsuits and risks
1 closed matter names the franchisor
XP Investments, LLC, Alphonse Marciulionis, Jr. and Maria Marciulionis v. Auto Select,… (concluded). 2 checks to read inside.
p. 8
2009 FDD, Item 3, page 8 · older sourceXP Investments, LLC, Alphonse Marciulionis, Jr. and Maria Marciulionis, Plaintiffs v. Auto Select, Inc. and Michael J. Molitor, Sr., Defendants and Frontier Communications of Wisconsin LLC and/or Frontier Communications Corporate Services Inc., Involuntary Defendants;Quoted from the franchisor's filing.Read page 8 free in a state registry's public copy of the filing.Get the FDD PDF · $9
Cases and checks
Things to check before you sign (2)
- The franchisor keeps the right to compete inside your territory (Item 12, territory).
- Limited data: this page holds only part of the filing. Read the FDD itself before relying on any figure here.
Checked and clear: no auditor doubt that the franchisor can keep operating, no pending lawsuit naming the franchisor, no jury-trial waiver, no supplier rebates to the franchisor and no rule that the owner must run it personally. Not on file here, so ask: unit trend and SBA charge-off rate against the category median.
Source: SBA 7(a) FOIA · FDD Items 3, 21
Verdict grade + FDD Items 3 (litigation), 4 (bankruptcy), 8 (required suppliers), 16 (what you may sell), 21 (audited financials)
Risk and legal
Grade B: Second tier, 50/100 (category median 58); the full grade is at the top of the page.
How the grade is built
Litigation (Item 3)
Subject: the franchisor is a named party (defendant).
XP Investments, LLC, Alphonse Marciulionis, Jr. and Maria Marciulionis v. Auto Select, Inc. and Michael J. Molitor, Sr.; Marathon County Case No. 19 CV 417
Bankruptcy (Item 4)
None disclosed
Audited financials (Item 21)
No audited financials on file
Supplier relationship · Items 8 & 16
Ask what the franchisor earns on the supplies it sells you or the rebates it takes (Item 8).
- Franchisor sells you products: Yes
- Franchisor takes supplier rebates: No
- Must buy proprietary products: Yes
- Restricted to system-approved products: Yes
- Franchisor negotiates, or may negotiate, supplier terms: Yes
Notes from the filing review · not the score inputs
- 01MEDNo average gross sales or net income disclosed — inability to assess unit-level profitability or ROI on $110K – $160K investment
- 02MINORUnknown unit count and growth trajectory — suggests shrinking or stagnant system with poor transparency
- 03MINORNo protected territory — franchisees face direct competition from other franchisees and corporate encroachment
- 04MINORRoyalty structure (greater of $700/month or 5%) creates high fixed costs on low-margin service business
- 05MINORMinimal franchise fee ($2,500) relative to total investment may indicate franchisor capital constraints or desperation
- 06MED10-year term is long-duration commitment with no disclosed break-even timeline or exit strategy
Severity inferred from the FDD text · not a regulatory classification
Auto Select franchise agreement terms
10 years
Initial term (Item 17); renewal, territory, training and suppliers inside.
All contract terms
FDD Items 12 (territory), 15 (owner participation) and 17 (renewal, termination and disputes)
Contract and territory detail
| Protected territory | No |
|---|---|
| Exclusive territory | No |
| Franchisor can compete | Yes |
| Who runs it (Item 15) | A manager may run it |
| Non-compete (years) | 1 year |
| Non-compete (miles) | 5 mi |
| Right of first refusal | Yes |
| Transfer requires consent | Yes |
| Termination notice | 90 days |
| Mandatory arbitration | Yes |
| Arbitration location | Wisconsin |
| Jury trial waiver | No |
| Governing law | WI |
Items 10 (financing), 11 (training and support)
Training and operations
- Ongoing training
- Required
- Time to open
- 3–9 mo
- From signing to launch (FDD p.19)
- Site selection
- Franchisee selects, franchisor must approve
- Franchisor financing
- Not offered
- Item 10
Items 5 (initial fees) & 11 (training and support)
Franchisor support
Auto Select pros and cons
0 pros · 2 cons
Held back by scale and transparency.
Pros, cons and peers
Why a B, factor by factor
- Financial health NeutralNo audited financials on file; no going-concern doubt
- Unit economics NeutralNo Item 19 sales figure to set against the investment, so neutral
- Unit growth NeutralNo Item 20 trend on file, so neutral
- Scale Weighs on it, weakest dimensionFranchising since 2005
- Legal Neutral1 matter naming the franchisor among the Item 3 matters we list
- Transparency Weighs on itItem 19 status not confirmed (neither credit nor penalty); no audited financials; no franchisor financial figures on file
- Adjustments after the six dimensions (-10 points)Filing age: the newest filing on file is from 2009, and older filings may no longer describe the system, so it took 10 points off.
From the six scored dimensions, an editorial assessment, not investment advice. How the score is built
Who are you contracting with?
Auto Select, Inc.
Item 1 (the franchisor) · who you're contracting with
The franchisor
Corporate structure & franchisor financials
- Legal entity
- Auto Select, Inc.
- CEO title
- Owner and President
- Michael J. Molitor, Sr.
- Incorporated in
- WI
- HQ
- 614 Lances Circle, Hatley, WI 54440
| Brand | Investment (Item 7) | Item 19 average | Units (Item 20) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Spiffy(B) | $102K – $181K | $1.1M | 38 |
| HHO Carbon Clean Systems(B) | $108K – $185K | Not stated | 15 |
| Kennedy Transmission® Brake & Auto Service(B) | $89K – $163K | Not stated | 7 |
| Alloy Wheel Repair Specialists(B) | $100K – $214K | $391K | 87 |
| ALSET Auto(B) | $103K – $179K | Not stated | 12 |
Each brand's own latest FDD. Item 19 averages are gross sales, not profit, and brands measure them differently.
Next steps before you buy an Auto Select franchise
3 steps
Read the FDD 14 days before you sign, call current and former owners, talk to an SBA lender and a franchise attorney.
The Auto Select FDD report · $19
- Every fee and Item 7 cost we read from the filing, by Item
- The Item 20 unit counts, and the questions to ask about them
- Questions for your attorney, by Item
Full refund within 7 days if the data does not match the FDD. · sample
Compare before you decide
- Auto Select vs Spiffy
- Auto Select vs HHO Carbon Clean Systems
- Auto Select vs Kennedy Transmission® Brake & Auto Service
Already own an Auto Select? Benchmark your numbers against the filing
Steps and questions to ask
What to do next
Step 1: Read the FDD itself.
Free: the franchisor must give you its current FDD at least 14 days before you sign or pay. Or read the public copy in a state registry (Wisconsin, Minnesota, California). What to read first.
Step 2: Talk to current and former owners.
Free: Item 20 of the FDD lists every current owner and those who left last year, most with a phone number. Questions to ask.
Step 3: Talk to an SBA lender.
Free: the SBA's Lender Match. Ask what you would personally guarantee and what the monthly payment would be. If you plan to use retirement savings, ask a CPA about the rules for that first.
Research steps, not investment or legal advice. Before you sign, have a franchise attorney review the FDD and the agreement: your state bar's lawyer referral service can name one, and many offer a short first consultation.
Auto Select franchise FAQ
6 answers
Cost, fees, earnings, closures, ownership, SBA loans and territory, each answered with the number first.
All questions
Frequently asked questions
How much does it cost to open an Auto Select franchise?
Per the 2009 FDD, the total investment to open an Auto Select franchise ranges from $110K to $160K, with an initial franchise fee of $3K. This is the Item 7 total in the Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD): the startup costs the franchisor lists, such as build-out, equipment, inventory and working capital. It usually leaves out buying land or a building; Item 7's notes say what is excluded.
What do Auto Select franchise owners earn?
No average owner earnings figure for Auto Select is on file. Item 19, where a franchisor may disclose what its outlets earn, is voluntary under the FTC Franchise Rule, and we have not established what this brand's FDD says. Item 20 of the FDD lists current and former franchisees; asking them directly is the standard way to fill this gap.
Who owns Auto Select?
Auto Select is franchised by Auto Select, Inc. Source: FDD Item 1, 2009 filing.
What is Item 19 in the Auto Select FDD?
The FDD section where a franchisor may disclose financial performance of its outlets. Disclosure is optional and formats vary; figures are typically gross sales, which is revenue before expenses, not profit. FranchiseVerdict extracts these figures directly from the Auto Select FDD and qualifies whose outlets they describe.
What is Auto Select's franchise failure rate?
There is no published franchise failure rate, and Auto Select has too few resolved SBA 7(a) loans on file (fewer than 10) to show an SBA charge-off rate that would mean anything. The SBA charge-off rate is the share of a brand's resolved SBA 7(a) loans to its franchisees that the SBA wrote off, including purchased guarantees. Resolved means paid in full or charged off; active loans are excluded because their outcome is not yet known. It is a lending outcome, not a count of closed businesses. Review the turnover and closure figures in Item 20 of the FDD and speak with current and former franchisees.
Is Auto Select a good franchise to buy?
FranchiseVerdict gives Auto Select a B Verdict grade (Second tier) with a verdict score of 50 out of 100 (higher is better), an editorial assessment, not investment advice. Held back by scale (franchising since 2005) and transparency (Item 19 status not confirmed: neither credit nor penalty). The “Why a B” section on this page lists all six dimensions and any adjustment. Speak with current franchisees before making any investment decision.
Sources
2009 FDD
Every FDD figure is read from the filing, with its page (4 of 4 headline figures cite one). Loans: SBA 7(a) records.
All sources and page cites
Source pages
- FDD 2009, Item 7, p. 4 Total investment, Working capital
- FDD 2009, Item 5, p. 8 Franchise fee
- FDD 2009, Item 3, p. 8 Litigation, Lawsuits headline
- FDD 2009, Item 6, p. 9 Royalty, Ongoing fees
- FDD 2009, Item 15, p. 22 Owner-Operator
Open a chip beside a figure for the line it reads. The filing itself is free in a state registry's public copy.
FDD issued: 2009 filing · Data extracted: · Last cited check: · Staleness risk: high (figures are from a filing two or more years old)
Evidence for the headline figures: partial✓ Investment (Item 7)✗ Item 19 status✓ Units and owners (Item 20)✗ SBA loan coverage✓ Litigation (Item 3)✓ Financial statements (Item 21)✓ Franchisor identityhow this is scored4 of 4 headline figures on this page cite a page of the filing.
- [1]U.S. Small Business Administration: 7(a) loan-level disclosures released under the Freedom of Information Act. How the rate is computed: methodology.
- [2]Auto Select 2009 Franchise Disclosure Document, Items 5 (initial fees), 6 (recurring fees), 7 (initial investment), 19 (financial performance), 20 (unit counts and turnover), filed with state franchise regulators under FTC rule 16 CFR 436. Filed by Auto Select, Inc. Read this filing.
How each headline figure is sourced
Verified: printed in the filing and restated elsewhere in it, or re-derived from the table's own arithmetic. Cited, not corroborated: printed on the page named, with nothing else in our record restating it. Not cited: published from our reading of the filing; the page has not been located.
- [3]How the verdict grade is built: methodology.
Recent checks against the filing (8)
- · Is pre opening · read from page 7 of the 2009 FDD
- · Local ad spend pct · read from page 19 of the 2009 FDD
- · Can negotiate with suppliers · read from page 12 of the 2009 FDD
- · Initial franchise fee · read from page 8 of the 2009 FDD
- · Franchise fee high · read from page 8 of the 2009 FDD
- · Franchise fee low · read from page 8 of the 2009 FDD
- · Litigation matters · read from page 8 of the 2009 FDD
- · Time to open · read from page 19 of the 2009 FDD
By the FranchiseVerdict editorial team · Reviewed against the 2009 FDD ·
Cite this page
Citation
FranchiseVerdict. "Auto Select franchise profile." Source: 2009 Franchise Disclosure Document and SBA 7(a) loan data. Updated November 15, 2026. https://franchiseverdict.com/brand/auto-select
Link for a web page
<a href="https://franchiseverdict.com/brand/auto-select">Auto Select franchise profile (FranchiseVerdict)</a>
Free to quote with a link. Figures come from the filing or federal loan data named above; grades are FranchiseVerdict's editorial assessment, not investment advice. Press and data requests: press@franchiseverdict.com
This information is provided for research purposes only and does not constitute financial, legal, or investment advice. Verify all figures with the franchisor's current Franchise Disclosure Document before making any investment decision.